Aristocrat Challenge - The Blessed Bant

Comments

• ningyounk

  February 2017

  @sanjaya666 What? I don't remember your previous entry but I also don't remember saying any entry was stupid O_o Please don't take my comments too harshly, they're just a personal opinion meant to pinpoint what I think could be improved, but I don't want to offend you. If you're uncomfortable with me giving feedback on your cards I can totally refrain, really I don't mean to make anyone feel bad
• Faiths_Guide

  February 2017 edited February 2017

  @ningyounk
  I'm sure it wasn't any fault of yours.
  
  @sanjaya666,
  Most people on the site (especially ningyounk) are genuinely trying to help when they provide criticism or any other kind of constructive comment. The recipients of such assistance need to make sure they don't overreact if they find the comment not to their liking. Even more importantly, they mustn't report that the person in question said things they didn't. Doesn't always feel good to find out you made mistakes with a design (I do it all the time), but help with pointing out these mistakes should never be scorned.
  
  
• sanjaya666

  February 2017 edited February 2017

  @ningyounk
  I wasn't angry or whatever it was towards you. I only said that my card was stupid because it was really stupid and you just pointed it out. I wasn't offended anyway. It's even nice when people can give me feedback.
• sanjaya666

  February 2017 edited February 2017

  Deleted lol.
  
  @Faiths_Guide
  Okay baws.
  
• Faiths_Guide

  February 2017

  @sanjaya666
  Cool, not pointing fingers. *thumbsup*
  Glad that no anger was harbored.
• sanjaya666

  February 2017

  @Corwinnn
  Changed my entry.
• Corwinnn

  February 2017

  I totally got that @sanjaya666! I like the new one better too!
  XD
• Faiths_Guide

  February 2017

  I wonder if I should switch once more...
  
  Make her a Human Scout Advisor?
• Corwinnn

  February 2017

  Just a few hours left!
• Rubieus

  February 2017 edited February 2017

  
• Corwinnn

  February 2017

  Challenged closed for judging!!! Thank you to everyone who entered!!!
• Corwinnn

  February 2017 edited March 2017

  I wasn't sure how well this would go, but there are a lot more good cards than I thought we would get. That makes it more difficult to judge, but it's always a good problem to have!
  
  Special Thanks...
  @sanjaya666
  @HenryTheHatter
  @hivelord3
  @Sweepea38
  @Inzeen
  @Rubieus
  Thank you for the entries! Some tough competitors kept you from getting to the top, but there are some really fun entries in here! Great work!
  
  Honorable Mentions...
  @Faiths_Guide
  @KJMartin
  @kimandbech
  @Flatfish
  Your cards were on the cusp of making the top three, but the final three just managed to edge yours out. You made this difficult for some of our up and coming Cardsmiths to crack the top.
  
  Top Three...
  
  Third Place - Goldleaf Storyteller by @ningyounk
  http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/goldleaf-storyteller-2
  Really great art and cool ability! This is a card I would love to see expanded on and a mechanic I would love to explore! Great Work!
  
  Second Place - Bant Aristocrat by @AustinSmith
  http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/bant-aristocrat
  I appreciate the nod to the original Aristocrat challenges, and I like where you took this with the Artwork and the abilities!
  
  First Place - Prishna, Advocate of Akrasa by @Animist
  http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/prishna-advocate-of-akrasa
  This one feels, to me, like a top to bottom Bant Aristocrat, without being overworked. The art and flavor really work well with the abilities! Great job!!
  
  Coming Soon -
  -Trophy-
  
  
  Hall of Fame - http://forums.mtgcardsmith.com/discussion/comment/68748/#Comment_68748