MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Masterpeice Contest - Challenge 2
This discussion has been closed.
Howdy, Stranger!
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
Comments
Ill have the judging in tommorow if i have the time.
Can't stress how sorry I am guys!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Participants: (15)
@zizick123 @Mnemosyne @Gryphon1114 @DarthPon3 @MaverickGV @theimmortaldeath @Kinojitsu_Asahi @ShadowKnight1224 @LyndonF @kltmtg29 @Tomble123 @Rednaxela @DomriKade @unicornsareevil13579 @Tesarand
Judge: MEEEEEE..... a very tired meeeee!
@zizick123
No Entries - Eliminated.
@Mnemosyne
Revoked participation - Eliminated.
@Gryphon11114
"Gateway to Cursed Life" (Entry 1)
Total of 29.5 Score.
- 31/40. A strong unique card, but I think its just WAY too powerful for a six-drop artifact...
"Sunken Ship of the Cursed"
- 28/40. I don't really undertstand the flavour text fully, and I'm not sure that it's strong enough for a 5-drop vehicle as a 4/8 with crew 4.
@Darthpon3
Total of 15 Score.
"Map of the Cursed Crew"
- 20/40. Im not sure how a map could buff creaturs and turn them into pirates, but I suppose the map lead them to the Citadel. A few minor spelling/punctuational mistakes. But I think its way too weak for a masterpeice card - which are meant to be really strong.
"Arina, Eluvian Wake"
-10/40. Im just going to be blunt here, This is not an artifact... Its an Elf pirate... Thus its not really a Masterpeice. And the majority of spelling mistakes and mistemplating is really eye-catching, and the card itself doesn't make much sense to me.
@MaverickGV
No Entries - Eliminated
@theimmortaldeath
Total of 36.5 Score
"The Accursed Citadel"
- 38/40. A very strong, balanced card that makes total sense to be a Masterpeice.
"The Cruel Shark"
-35/40. Pretty strong card, though you can get caught up reading in what it does, and it can be confusing. Though it is fairly balanced, it could do with some falvour text. Cool art though.
@Kinojitsu_Asahi
No Entries - Eliminated
@Shadowknight1224
Total of 36.5 Score
"Crown of Frozen Whispers"
- 39.5/40. A reaaally strong, yet reaally balanced card. I can imagine a set of crowns with similar but opposing abilities for the colour wheel. Congrats on 39.5/40!
"Elixir of Regret"
- 34.5/40. Strong-ish and balanced-ish, but could do with some empowering. Should reward the controller more I think.
@Lyndon_F
Total of 34/40
"Vault of Desire"
-38/40. Good card..... Awesome! Balanced with nice art.. I guess.
"Lisburne 1 + 2"
- 30/40. I THINK ITS A BIT TOO STRONG. But seriously, 4-drop for extreme ramp of crew 3 for 6 mana if you prevent damage? Dam son! Should cost more i think, and the transform should leave some kind of penalty.
@kltmtg29
Total of 33/40
"Cursed Chest"
- 30/40. Im not sure its rewarding enough for risking yourself to lose the game, Surely enough you could destroy it before it kills you but only one mana each turn? I think maybe two or three mana a turn.
"Overwhelming Desire"
- 36/40. I guess this is cool, because you can put it in token decks for a little ramp - but im sure there alot of 3-drops that do the same thing as this quicker, but maybe a little bit of strengthening on it. It is a Masterpeice after all.
@Tomble123
No entries - Eliminated
@Rednaxela
Total of 37/40
"High Tide Relic"
- 37/40. I get the sense that this would be a real masterpeice card. I think the only improvement you could make would be to change it to a 3 colourless cost and have it choose a colour when it enters.
@DomriKade
"Temporarium"
Total score of (CONFETTI) 39.5 (/CONFETTI)
-40/40. Im totally blown away at how awesome this card is, and I would personally beg Wizards of the Coast to create it if I were given the chance. Its a strong card that is very balanced, I can picture this being used without it being oppressive, yet not being too weak. Congrats!
"Liquimetal Pearl"
-39/40. Again, im totally blown away. Even its categorisation of Liquimetal carries onto the abilities, with the tradition of card naming... And its again, totally balanced and a strong card. Congrats on first place.
@unicornsareevil13579
36.5/40
"Jewel of Ice"
39.5/40. The card is very balanced and strong, but I think you could put it down as a three drop with no blue cost and it would be masterpeice material!!!! But congratulations nonetheless.
"Treasure of the Cursed Crew"
- 33.5/40. Strong and balanced, but maybe could be a two-drop so it would be powerful enough for masterpeice material? Excellent card nonetheless.
@Tesarand
Revoked participation - Eliminated
Participants for FINAL ROUND:
Participants: (15)
@Gryphon1114 @DarthPon3 @theimmortaldeath @ShadowKnight1224 @LyndonF @kltmtg29 @Rednaxela @DomriKade @unicornsareevil13579
DRUMROLLLLLL
Top 3:
#1 - @DomriKade with "Temporarium" (CONFETTI)
#2 - Rednaxela with "High Tide Relic"
#3 - Tied @unicornsareevil, @ShadowKnight1224, @theimmortaldeath
Ill post final round post within a week.... It won't be 2 months late this time =D
Again, sorry for the delay. First place next contest gets a AER Booster!
New prize updates:
#1 - 1 AER Booster + Foil Promo "Yahenni's Expertise" (I pulled it at my LGS)
#2 - 1 AER Booster
Good luck in the next contest.
I'm coming for you round 3