Simplicity is Key

hivelord3 · February 2017

here you go

TrippleBoggey3 · February 2017

Bump

MaverickGV · February 2017

Apparently is breaks the system if you try and save a card with no name

MaverickGV · February 2017

HenryTheHatter · February 2017

http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/negative
Where's my instant win?

HenryTheHatter · February 2017

http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/no-72
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/bargain-4

TrippleBoggey3 · February 2017

Judging now!

TrippleBoggey3 · February 2017

Judging

@Rednaxela - Sporeling reflects an idea that has a capacity of flavor, yet I feel you added so much flavor and complexity to the idea, that the idea of simplicity seems to be decimated. 7.5/10.

@Flatfish - That card's reminder text is longer and more complex than half the cards on the whymtgcardsmith! I understand it's a joke. 7/10.

@UndeadZombie22 - I believe I've seen that card somewhere... 5/10

@BraveJRL - I don't exactly see a point to this card. It feels so... bland. And the flavor text? That made my friend crack up next to me. "I am Death" - "I am Groot" 6/10

@Gelectrode - I believe I mentioned... 1 word names! DQed.

@IanLowenthal - This card looks very simple, but the flavor and idea behind it feels amazing. 8.25/10!

@Animist - Almost too perfect! This card can be used in so many ways! 8/10!

@Faiths_Guide - Horselords with Horsemanship? My favorite mechanic! Oh thank you thanks you!!! But it's still a 7/10... I wish I could let that card win, but I gotta be fair.

Ringform is really amazing too! It has so many ways to use it! 8.5/10.

@Poseidan847 - What...

@Awticon - The card seems to be a bit too overpowered... Never mind, a lot too overpowered!

@Karmadragon - It's a good idea, just might have some off wording. I'll give it a 8.125/10.

@IanLowenthal - I don't think the trades worth it. 6.5/10.

@hivelord3 - That cards way underpowered. 6/10.

@MaverickGV - That wasn't exactly what I wanted to see. And why is that a conceptual art of Trump's wall?

@Henrythehater - All those cards are too cheap, and don't match what I was asking for.

Announcement

Just a short thing before I show results - I believe @KJMartin lost the bet and now owes me 10 favorites...

Winners

5th Place - @Flatfish! You may send me one card for me to favorite, or request for flavor text help, card help, etc.

4th Place - @Animist! You may send me two cards for me to favorite, or request for flavor text help, card help, etc.

3rd Place - @Karmadragon! You may send me three cards for me to favorite, or request for flavor text help, card help, etc.

2nd Place - @IanLownthal! You may send me four cards for me to favorite, or request for flavor text help, card help, etc.

1st Place - @Fairhs_Guide! You may send me five cards for me to favorite, or request for flavor text help, card help, etc.

This contest is now closed.