MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Battle of the Champions
Rules
Each smith may post their card with the most favorites, with information on why they think it is so popular. Each smith may post up to 1 serious card with the most favorites, and up to 1 joke card with the most favorites. If you have a tie, you choose. If you made a card on an alternate account, you may post it here instead.
For reference, this is for me:
This contest is only to be used as a reference point for a new chain contest I will be starting. I cannot release the details of that, or the information of the prizes, because some people will refuse the prizes... You'll see. Either way, it'll be a nice little surprise. Oh yeah, technically everyone becomes a winner... By posting your entries here, you agree to participate in the large chain contest.
Each smith may post their card with the most favorites, with information on why they think it is so popular. Each smith may post up to 1 serious card with the most favorites, and up to 1 joke card with the most favorites. If you have a tie, you choose. If you made a card on an alternate account, you may post it here instead.
For reference, this is for me:
This contest is only to be used as a reference point for a new chain contest I will be starting. I cannot release the details of that, or the information of the prizes, because some people will refuse the prizes... You'll see. Either way, it'll be a nice little surprise. Oh yeah, technically everyone becomes a winner... By posting your entries here, you agree to participate in the large chain contest.
This discussion has been closed.
Comments
Would you like to fight @Faiths_Guide to death in a 1v1 battle?
Oh yeah, I still judge this in the end. This is just so I can set a standard for myself of the cardsmiths here.
The only reason I can possibly think of for this to be popular is because it's an unconventional lord related to what was the most recent set at the time, and is arguably cute.
Serious:
Joke
Joke:
Tbh, I don't know why either of these have as many favorites as they do.
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/bunny-tactician
I guess it has so many favourites because Id say it is an all-around decent card that enables potential bunny-tribal all on its own, while being fairly costed and and not too over the top. Also the artwork is pretty sweet.
Feel free to close this one and use mine if you like.
That wouldn't be wise since submission here enters you into a larger chain contest in the future...
That's true, but TrippleBoggey3 could just ask everyone who commented there, or just create a sign-ups page.
I don't remember why Chef Myr was so popular. I think it was a combination of the Art, Functionality, and the delicious flavor the Chef Myr cooked up for us. His brother was not nearly as popular. (Thanks for the one like it did get @Corwinnn
In @Corwinnn's words: "I don't think I'm alone in saying that this one knocked it out for me! Beautiful art and a great use of the mechanic!" This card was an idea I had for Mechanix Challenge 17. At first, I thought Death Turtle seemed pretty bad, although I thought it was a fun card so I posted it anyways. After a brief spree of testing to try the Turtle in my actual cube (Where it narrowly replaced Swift Warkite), I understood the raw power of this card. In actuality, it is my 3rd most popular card, just under False God, but I decided to post it instead since I felt the Myr was pretty silly.
Cheers!,
Kramp
@Faiths_Guide is right. I couldn't use your thread just for cards, since I need this to be like a sign up sheet. A sign ups sheet isn't enough, because I need this to set standards, and to do help with a few preliminary disqualifications.
Krystyn was a featured card for about a week. Probably something to do with the combination of +0/+1 and Persist. She just doesn't want anything to die, or in her words "I will not let nature fall." BFFs with Melira, Sylvok Oucast.
I would delete this card, but it has to many favorites attached to it. I have no idea why this card was so popular. I think maybe it was because it was an impressive and imaginative way to break bestow into a million overpowered pieces. (this is my second most popular card. I personally like it better.)
@Lujikul I really like that card. I still remember it from my contest.
I think that this card was popular just because of how stupid he would be to actually use, Idk.
I think it's because it is a blue planeswalker that actually uses creatures.
Joke