MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Post your cards here, see what others think
This discussion has been closed.
Howdy, Stranger!
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
Comments
Situational
Please try to edit your past comments rather than post three in a row!
What we don't approve of is attacking one another for disagreements and name calling.
Not everyone will agree, or think your card is as wonderful as you think it is...
(My example card... WhyMTGCardsmith felt I didn't know what "Cumulative Upkeep" meant, but I felt they didn't understand this would never see the turn I had to pay it's cumulative upkeep, if I decided to even pay it!)
...and they really don't have to. The bottom line is, if you like the card, then it's a good card. That's the beauty of MTGCardsmith. It doesn't have to be perfect, it just has to be yours.
So give criticism constructively and accept criticism graciously, but also keep in mind no one else has to like your card, as long as you do!
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/hope-filled-energy?list=user
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/mortis-grace
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/chewbacca-and-his-squirrel
Just wanted to know if the dragons are too big
Modnation675 and myself are working on our recent Angel pair and are looking for feedback to make sure the wording and theme are fine. Hopefully we may get some more feedback as we've been revising each of their wordings to function properly and more satisfyingly!
(Both designed especially for Commander.)
Rules Explanation: In multiplayer games (2+ players) a player cannot win the game if an opponent cannot lose the game. Hence Erene's abilities have been re-worded to follow this ruling!
Update: This post has been updated as of 1:11AM March 13th, 2017 according to Central time in MB, Canada.
An idea for a transform card that I had, not sure about the formatting and wether or not it would be OP, comments and criticism are greatly accepted.
how about this?
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/sword-of-life-and-death-5?list=user
Inspired by an AMV of the song Sing Me To Sleep by Alan Walker! (or Official Music Video)
Update: This post has been updated as of 8:48PM March 10th, 2017 according to Central time in MB, Canada.
Dunno how to balance it though. Lul.
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/eternities-matrix?list=user
{t}: Exile a card from your hand.
You may play cards you own exiled by Eternities Matrix as long as you control Eternities Matrix.
"Hold that thought..."
BTW, do you have to be a premium member to post pics on forums?
Premium isn't required to post on the forums. It just provides additional features on the MTGCardsmith site for the most part. (Details Here)
For a quick guide on posting images look here!
Quick Guide (W/ Visual Aid)
We're also looking for opinions on the following features we're requesting. Hopefully they will be added!
Click here to provide feedback!
For the Tome, the only balancing I can see it needing is probably a mana cost on the activated ability, and the second ability to read 'opponent' instead of 'player'. Otherwise, I would totally play it in EDH.
Oh, and probably have it say 'another nonland permanent', because I have no idea what the interaction would be if someone used it to exile itself.