MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Come one, come all Closed
I want you all to make a card for each card type:
Artifact, Enchantment, Creature, Planeswalker, Instant, Sorcery, and Land.
Rules
Only one entry for each type.
Preferably no mixing the types, ie Artifact Creature. Please have a different submission for each.
They can do anything you want.
Only new cards.
Judging
Judging will be April 20th. (Maybe later depending on the number of entries)
1st Place: 5 favorites of their choice
2nd Place: 3 favorites of their choice
3rd Place: 1 favorite of their choice
I will follow anyone with 35 or more points.
Each card will judged out of 6 points. 1 point for each of the following:
MTG grammar, as well as proper English grammar.
Usability.
Balance.
Creativity.
Art selection.
Flavor text.
Artifact, Enchantment, Creature, Planeswalker, Instant, Sorcery, and Land.
Rules
Only one entry for each type.
Preferably no mixing the types, ie Artifact Creature. Please have a different submission for each.
They can do anything you want.
Only new cards.
Judging
Judging will be April 20th. (Maybe later depending on the number of entries)
1st Place: 5 favorites of their choice
2nd Place: 3 favorites of their choice
3rd Place: 1 favorite of their choice
I will follow anyone with 35 or more points.
Each card will judged out of 6 points. 1 point for each of the following:
MTG grammar, as well as proper English grammar.
Usability.
Balance.
Creativity.
Art selection.
Flavor text.
This discussion has been closed.
Comments
Also, does a vehicle count as an artifact, artifact creature, or both?
A vehicle is just an artifact, since it doesn't start out as a creature.
Assuming you're talking about the judging, I mean I'll favorite 5 cards of your choice you've made for 1st, 3 cards of your choice you've made for 2nd, and 1 card of your choice you've made for 3rd.
Thank you!
I'd prefer you didn't, but yes, it would count as creature, not artifact
Instant:
Enchantment:
Sorcery:
Planeswalker:
Artifact:
Land:
Creature:
Yep, it started on the 7th. You can edit your entries as many times as you want until the 20th, though.
Artifact:
Enchantment:
Instant:
Sorcery:
Land:
Planeswalker:
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/jace-illusionary-master-1?list=user
Instant:
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/raiders-tactics?list=user
Sorcery:
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/mind-shatter-9?list=user
Enchantment:
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/search-for-knowledge-4?list=user
Artifact:
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/aether-works-statue?list=user
Creature:
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/haunter-of-tharben?list=user
Land:
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/dragons-peak-2?list=user
BTW Jace is my most favorite character
Sorcery:
Instant:
Creature:
Land:
Artifact:
Planeswalker:
Seems a lot of these cards are based on reflections, copies, and mirrors: I promise I didn't do this intentionally.
you might want to look at grammar mechanics on them or you might get penalized
Enchantment ------------------------------------ Artifact
Creature ---------------------------------------- Land
Planeswalker
Do you mean the ability is too long for the card?
Judging will be sometime tomorrow
As I didn't quite have enough time to judge it today, I will instead judge it sometime within the next 2 or 3 days. I'll try to get it done as soon as I can.
1st: @TenebrisNemo with 37 points! You can send me 5 cards to favorite. I will also follow you, as you have over 35 points. Congratulations!
2nd: @Credius with 33 points! You can send me 3 cards to favorite.
3rd: @TrumpetGaming with 28 points! You can send me 1 card to favorite.
As for everyone else, here are the points:
@Mellenius with 27 points.
@Baron-777 with 26 points. (You could have done much better if you hadn't just made a basic land and if you had made an enchantment.)
@Class with 22 points.
If you want any specific feedback on any of your cards or how many points they got, message me and we can talk.
@butterkirby , you may fave random cards in my repertoire of your own chosing xD