MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
POTION MAKING GAME
This discussion has been closed.
Howdy, Stranger!
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
Comments
I know it's pretty generic and kinda bad but good cards wouldn't be good without bad cards and same goes for interesting ones. I feel this to be Realistic
Edit: Seems I'm unable to find the artwork I'm looking for currently. As such it seems I'll be out of this challenge disappointingly.
I can help what do you need
Could an entry over here, but I can't edit once it's submitted so I'd love some feedback!
Oh, whoops! Only one entry.
I'll just keep my other Potion then.
I made a slight modification to Aether Elixir.
(Here's a link to this awesome artwork, click here!)
Nice card, by the way!
Thank you, I'll do so right away.
@Millenius Though powerful, the all players clause helps mitigate this.
@Sanjaya666 Your brewing mechanic is very functional and in afterthought can be flavorful, looking back at what went into the potion. The effect isn't too potiony, but in this case it doesn't really matter too much.
@MagicChess Your concept is one of the most flavorful and I would love to see a block with faeries, alchemists, intelligent animals.
@Class I really love your ingredient cards, especially at varying rarities. Maybe they can have cycling 2 (or 1 and appropriate color [eye of newt 1g]) so they are never dead in your hand?
@Baron-777 Though a little complicated, I really like the idea of this card.
@Jyagaimasu Super unique. There is something about the mechanic that reminds me of cooking.
@Brainifyer The modular nature of this card is super cool. I like things with options.
@Odogom This is a balanced alternate win condition and it has great flavor.
@Faiths_Guide Energy and potions seem like a good mix. Its like the energy gives you power to counter spells!
@Decaldor Transform is utilized nicely here. Curse potions are always fun.
@Tenebris_nemo The flavor is tight here and the potion costs match up nicely.
@Tsukuyomi_Lumen I like this. A very green 1,000 year elixer. Clean design.
@ABiscuit An excellent design based on the nature of the heart. Versatile and useful.
Overall, this was very difficult to judge. I really feel most people brought their A game. I decided to add Honorable Mentions for a like each.
HMs: @Sanjaya666 @ASubtleGhost @Odogom
3rd: @Brainifyer
2nd: @MagicChess
1st: @Class
Congrats everyone!
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/sylvine
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/smoke-reaper
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/ancient-valley-of-secrets
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/nomadic-flame
Edit: Just wondering, was our entry not accepted or disqualified?
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/chronology
@pstmdrn, I'm actually considering doing just that.
Should we tell you which cards to favorite, or will you just look through our cards and choose yourself?