MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Circuit Challenge: Meet the Souls
This discussion has been closed.
Howdy, Stranger!
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
Comments
- Everybody besides Mark Rosewater
I know Rabiah...
What about Ulgrotha? Did someone make one for that?
Ya, I did Ulgrotha.
Sweet.
*ThumbsUp*
Fast judging, me likey
Props for quick judging. I aspire to be as productive as you. (Still have that one contest I never got around to...)
Honorable mentions:
Soul of Tarkir, by @TheCenterOfTheUniverse . Manifest wasn't the most powerful, but it was one of the most distinctive mechanics from Khans block, and I liked it. There wasn't really much connection to red, though. Also, why is the Soul of Tarkir a Cat?
Also Soul of Tarkir, by @ningyounk . Dragons are pretty much the Tarkir-iest thing you can do, and this is a solid design. But transformation is usually a blue or green thing, so a Boros dragon Soul seemed a little arbitrary. Good job, though.
Finally, Soul of Valla, by @sanjaya666 . There's not much to Valla in the lore right now, so I can appreciate that you took what little we know of the world and reflected it in a Soul. Good stuff.
And by the way, I'm 22 u walnut.
In third place:
Soul of Rabiah, by @Gelectrode . I loved the reference to Bazaar, but what really made this one a winner for me was how you used the protection ability to make some interesting interactions in deciding when you want to target yourself or your opponent. Very cool!
Second place:
Soul of Mirrodin, by @Brainifyer . I love the flavor here. The concept of a small and frail Soul for a world that's been 99% consumed by darkness is brilliant flavor, and the execution was excellent. Clever, and a job well done!
First place:
Soul of Amonkhet, by @NokiSkaur . This thing is a flavor home run! Undeath is the overriding theme of Amonkhet, and this card captures that mechanic perfectly, while still being fair. Plus, the ability to return itself as a token is a brilliant twist on the Souls mechanic, and the flavor of the Soul of an undead-world returning to life after being killed by a being that never really understood it is just fantastic. I loved this card. Congratulations.
And congratulations to the other winners and HMs as well! @Corwinnn will see to your circuit challenge points, as I understand it, and the winners can DM me for their prize likes.
And new to this season, Circuit Challenge hosts will earn 1/2 a point!
My choices are:
Moonlight Reaper
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/moonlight-reaper
Masked Cutthroat
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/masked-cutthroat
Angelic Weaponsmith
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/angelic-weaponsmith
And Pinta.
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/pinta-toxic-renegade
On a separate note, I'm working on a story for Pinta, set a few months after the events of Aether Revolt. If anyone would like to read it over, I can send it over DMs.