MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Post your cards here, see what others think
This discussion has been closed.
Howdy, Stranger!
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
Comments
Why does it need to be evasive? Besides, skulk isn't evergreen as you mentioned.
I guess it doesn't have to be evasive perse, but I don't really like spirits without evasion. It's kinda like capitalizing custom mechanics in the middle of a sentence--it's not necessary, but I don't feel right if I don't do it.
I think that you could look at it a little differently since they look more corporeal and as such more like living corpses/skeletons. In addition, they look like they'd walk even if they can fly given their appearance.
Yeah, one of the reasons I didn't give them flying is because it wouldn't make sense with the art.
With those thoughts in mind, what do you think? Still the same? I plan on putting it into MSE or Untap.in to test it out as a card.
Here's the next iteration of my Transcendence cycle. I feel like this one is Much stronger than the Temur one, so I set it at 5 mana instead of 3, any thoughts?
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/leliel-angel-of-night
Made this one a while ago as an example for a contest I hosted, but I've always liked it alot. Anyone got any ideas?
I like the green and blue ones, but the others feel less impacting. Which makes it hard to justify putting red into the deck. Aside from that, it'd be cool to see the piper be 2/2 or stronger to increase play-ability.
Either way, we think you did a great job with the creature type!
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/accomplished-sculptor
Thank you! Presiding Narrator could be modified and end up mono-blue and I have another piece of art depicting a many masked performer
However, I have a feeling red would get in on a performance somehow.
I can't tell if this is too expensive or not. If anything, it's probably too cheap. Any thoughts?
Well, looking at this with the fact it's a common, It's an extremely good card at 3 mana. If it was rare, maaaybe even uncommon, you can drop paying one to activate it, or make it 2 mana.
Would it be helpful if I dropped discarding and changed the ability to 'Draw a card, then discard a card at random'?
Thoughts?
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/dakrasian-underworld
@Gelectrode That card is absolutely amazing, and the flavor text is super
The trample was a bit of a stretch since it's only tertiary in blue, but it seems worth it. What do you think?
Given the low stats and the supporting theme, I think it's reasonable.
Otherwise, it's a really well made card
@Sullyman I'll admit, it is keyword soup, but It is completely in color and I feel it would play well. And they do keyword soup creatures every once in awhile (see Akroma), and I've seen the occasional ask on Blogatog for more, so I figured some people like them
I really like Woods of Takama! Maybe make the third ability {1} less?
Thoughts?
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/haldran-wayward-warpriest
Feels a little bit too hard to connect using each ability. Which makes it feel like an under-powered deathtouch creature and not like a legendary.
Jester's Cap is a sweet and spicy card so I made a twist on it in the form of a creature.
I like the card a lot. It's just too easy to trigger for its power level.
Edit: It could also use a class sub-type and flavor text.
Yes, I can respect that idea. The other feedback still stands though.