MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Post your cards here, see what others think
This discussion has been closed.
Howdy, Stranger!
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
Comments
...Thoughts?
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/paradigm-r5-t4
sry gelectrode wrong person
You should enter too!
I think Homicidal Seclusion is cool, it just needs some support.
Also, Paradigm feels like it'd be perfectly at home in Unstable.
[REDACTED]
@Damnation, I do appreciate the flavor of Homicidal Seclusion, but I still feel uncomfortable applying those kinds of restrictions. I have probably said it before, but it's like Hellbent and the weird Sotomari hand size thing, where you have to play badly to win. It just seems counterintuitive.
*sound of explosions in backgound, goblins and wizards screaming*
Oops, a group of paradoxes must have been released. Be right back. What was I saying about being counterintuitive?
Thoughts?
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/servo-savant
Fun^
Thoughts on the couple of new rares?
- Are those my test subjects you're experimenting with? Do I need to alert the Senate?
- Also, Sotomari? I'd appreciate it if you could link this "Sotomari". Or is that heckbent?
Servo Savant
The card is interesting, I can see some cool stuff being done with it. Miniature value-town in one card, not to mention it is colorless. Of course, it fits more in an artifact-centric deck, but even by itself, you get two 3/3s for 4, which isn't too bad for an uncommon, although they are spaced out so you don't have both at once. Or you can just go 4/4 for 4 and then drop 3 +1/+1 counters on whatever artifact creature you control.
@Faiths_Guide
Noble Ruler
I think this is pushing it for a rare. The hosing part doesn't seem too bad, but the Vengeful trigger is doing too much, I think. In a dedicated tribal deck, this is an Intrepid Hero on steroids, to say the least. Or it can be, if enough things die.
Dragonite Learner
I think you could do more for this. It has no evasion or protection, and has the dreaded 1 toughness, so I don't think you'll ever be making the Dragon with it's ability anything more than a 3/3 the majority of the time. Sure, the ability's free so it can go off even if someone Doom Blade's it, but that 1 toughness is going to put you in a tough spot a lot of times, since it will die to the smallest of things.
Thoughts? In particular, is the first one too much of a colour break?
Opinions, anyone?
Maybe reveal your whole hand when you activate her ability before you exile a card or if you limit the mana cost of that card or if you instead reduce cost of it by some amount.
@TenebrisNemo I think it looks nice.
Thoughts? Too powerful first ability for the cost? too expensive second ability? Should I give him hexproof?
@Jonteman93: better now?
When ~ enters the battlefield, if you cast it during combat, you may have it block target attacking creature. If you do, it gets +2/+2 until end of turn.
@KalamMekhar, I really like the concept of Sumitra! My only suggestion is to give it the proper white/blue border to make it look extra nice.
Thoughts?
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/brightstone-rampage
@Gelectrode: Aaaand, done!
Need some help with the wording. I'm sure it can be worded much more elegantly.
Too good for uncommon, or just right?
-Deathmatch
First strike doesn't work in fighting. Even if one of the creature has first strike and the other is vanilla, each deals damage to the other at the same time. So you have to rethink about the card's mechanic. The concept seems fun. I think it should have red in its cost.
-Grim Tidings
I think the card is balanced.
@Tomigon: I have no clue how I missed that! Here's a new version. And you are right, the randomness involved seems quite red.
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/darmani-the-liberator
Write-up in comments tomorrow, it is night where I am as of now.