MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
1 mana 2/2
This discussion has been closed.
Howdy, Stranger!
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
Comments
Please could you publish the card and re-post? At the moment it's just an image link.
As mentioned earlier, I'll be judging the best common / uncommon / rare rather than the top three. However, if we can get at least 20 entries for each rarity then I'll judge the top three in each rarity for a total of 9 winners.
The list of entries is on the first page. At the moment we have over 20 commons and uncommons but we're just short in the rare category with 17 cards. We just need three more rare entries!! (and of course feel free to post commons and uncommons as well if you haven't already).
Three more rare entries and you get to triple my workload! Who wouldn't want to do that? :S
Which reminds me... - Would anyone like to help me judge this? If so, shoot me a PM (preference to those who haven't entered but it's okay if you have - you can still be both a judge and participant).
Also, I realised I didn't specify prizes earlier. Probably favourites since I can't really think of anything else at the moment :P
There's still time for those entries! Get them in and there'll be thrice the prizes!
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/shadowblood-ronin
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/angel-of-darkness-11?list=user
The contest is still open for entries for the rest of the day!
With this, I was going for balance and flavor- although then again, tower's can't move in the first place. I was thinking of it as on the offence, you can move it around slowly to attack, but if so your defences will be weaker. However, if you are being attacked, you are more focused on surviving and have less power.
Uncommon: http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/prowling-hunter-1?list=user Prowling Hunter
With this card I was thinking of a cat's perspective- they see some big, defensive, tough creature, they will attempt to take it down- however, if they see a looming, powerful, aggressive creature, they will back down and in general be weaker.
Rare: http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/eldrazi-caller-1?list=user Eldrazi Caller
So, for this I was thinking of an Eldrazi that rallied other Eldrazi to attack with it- with other Eldrazi, it is extremely powerful. However, alone, if no one answers it's call, it gets destroyed. Imagine if you topdecked this on a clear board. Not that useful, hm?
Thanks to everyone who contributed to this challenge - 68 entries in total!
It's going to take me a while to get through them all so please be patient. I'll aim to post the results in about a week's time.
*Thumbsup*
I should also note that I was judging the card, not the cardsmith. It didn't matter who you were, newcomer or veteran, and it didn't matter if you were a winner in more than one category.
So today's results are:
Common
1st place - Flesh Tormentor by @ningyounk
Joint 2nd place - Hoarfrost Elemental by @saveria201 and Battlefield Wanderer by @KimJongMartin
Joint 3rd place - Knight of the Knell by @Beeswax and Longhorn beetle by @MrRansom
Uncommon
1st place - Soul Nibblers by @koover
2nd place - Outrider of Iroas by @Oshuja89
Joint 3rd place - Decaying Moldform by @opcode_6e and Eldrazi Seedling by @seaspray4TF3
Rare
1st place - Archdemon of Mogis by @Oshuja89
2nd place - Strange Companions by @ningyounk
3rd place - Lurking Abomination by @koover
Thanks again everyone and congrats to all the winners.
Please PM me with which cards you'd like me to favourite. Prizes are as follows for each category:
1st place - 5 faves
2nd place - 3 faves
3rd place - 1 fave
Thanks
Oh cool, I got 2nd place
Holy heck! I also got first place!
I'll be back in a min with the 8 favorites
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/aura-of-the-elder-gods?list=user
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/aonar-macleod?list=user
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/grigorin-crusader-of-norn-1?list=user
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/golgarox-1?list=user
there's four, I guess. I can't think of anymore I'd like to get favorited, so I'll keep it at that. In the meantime I think I'm gonna try and make some mono blue spells. Most everything I want to make is multiple colors, or made with multiple colors in mind... Anyway, that's four
If you find any cards on my profile which you like and haven't favorited yet, feel free to do it now. That's enough for me as a "prize"
And if anyone else is interested, here's the 3/3 contest http://forums.mtgcardsmith.com/discussion/1873/1-mana-3-3
@Beeswax @KimJongMartin @seaspray4TF3 - don't forget to drop me a line if you'd like me to favourite any specific cards. Alternatively, I'll choose some that I like. Thanks!