Thanks @Ranshi. I was surprised by the results too, you do have a solid lineup. It must've been a matter of one card slightly edging out the other in each case, which looks way more extreme when you aggregate the match results. Whether the card scores were 51-49 or 90-10, it'll show as 1-0 for the winning cardsmith.
Hi pals - I'd like to invite you to join the Cardsmith League. You don't make cards for this, so it does NOT require any of your time. We look at your collection each week and judge the most recently made cards. In a 1-vs-1 match with another cardsmith, if we think your cards are better than their cards, you win the match that week. 4 times a year, we hand out prizes to champions like in the post above! We have a division for every level, so if you're interested, we're happy to have you.
@theirintheattic you remain in the league until you opt out - if you go inactive, we just temporarily remove you until you're active again, but keep tabs on your account
16 Votes - Majority must be 2/3 or more to Approve
Cards with Side A + Side B (ex: Transform cards) will be graded as one card, but count as two cards towards your 7.
Approved
Though flavor text factors into the overall design, the presence of flavor text vs no flavor text should be the main tiebreaker if judges split decision or give same grade for two cards.
Approved
We will re-judge your card if you make edits and let us know you've edited your card.
Disapproved
Like transform cards, any two cards meant to synergize or combo with each other in your recent 7 should be graded as one at the request of the cardsmith.
Disapproved
We're willing to provide a trial run this season to see if it's worth the time for the following:
1) A numerical rating of each card's design 1-100.
2) A sentence or less of notable reasons a newly judged card loses, if it loses.
@TheGamingBolasChannel One thing tho... avoid blank creatures... you know? Also, if you could put custom mechanics in the comments if it's not in the card
@TheGamingBolasChannel Thanks! I really honestly hate to give you more work... i don't want to... maybe we can figure something else out... like you can send me a message with your mechanic (as if it were on MTGFandom) that way we have it...
I just remember seeing plenty of cards with mechanics out of the blue, and until we memorize them... haha ... we forget what we're reading
Yeah. Plus with this one there are many new mechanics coming for the later featured planes, but if I can remember to add that info as a comment, that should be helpful to you.
MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Comments
B-League Championship
@Creid233 (4)(L) https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/fabricated-skinwalker?list=user
(W) https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/adak-del-the-elusive-1?list=user
(W) https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/adak-del-sparkthief-1?list=user
(W) https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/forged-in-conflict?list=user
(L) https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/lyssa-of-the-gloaming-hunt?list=user
(W) https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/altar-of-ascension?list=user
@MarvelousHavel (3)
(W) https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/aurean-god-of-the-sky?list=user
(L) https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/gane-the-white-1?list=user
(L) https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/transient-combatant?list=user
(L) https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/pendant-of-the-widowed-queen?list=user
(W) https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/betray-the-party?list=user
(L) https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/bog-veil-predation?list=user
B-League Champion @Creid233
We'll see what the survey says for that one after the season concludes thursday. Next season, we'd start that if the vote is in favor.
C-League Championship
@andylewis42037 (3)
(T) https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/ruins-of-baaj-temple?list=user
(L) https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/temple-of-bevelle?list=user
(L) https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/temple-of-macalania?list=user
(W) https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/temple-of-djose?list=user
(L) https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/temple-of-kilika?list=user
(W) https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/temple-of-besaid?list=user
---Sudden Death---
(L) https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/onion-knight-6?list=user
@Korora12 (4)
(T) https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/derlict-haas-shadow-king?list=user
(W) https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/blood-summons?list=user
(W) https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/illicit-dealings?list=user
(L) https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/interrogation-27?list=user
(W) https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/branch-of-the-granite-bank?list=user
(L) https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/insurance-appraisers?list=user
---Sudden Death---
(W) https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/landsculpting?list=user
C-League Champion @Korora12
Congratulations to our April-June 2023 Champions
(A) @12SidedGuy
(B) @Creid233
(C) @Korora12
(D) @stijnhommes
"And the Prize Breakdown for the winners of each Division!" - @Corwinnn
Division A - 2 Months Premium + 10 favorites +$10 Amazon + Featured Card
Division B - 2 Months Premium + 10 Favorites +$10 Amazon
Division C - 2 Months Premium + 10 Favorites +$10 Amazon
Division D - 1 Month Premium + 8 Favorites
Runner Ups
(A) @Jadefire
(B) @MarvelousHavel
(C) @andylewis42037
(D) @StuffnSuch
@Talidin1337
@kaoz42
@yiak65
@Burnabus
@BladeOfWinter
I've got you down for B to start.
you remain in the league until you opt out - if you go inactive, we just temporarily remove you until you're active again, but keep tabs on your account
16 Votes - Majority must be 2/3 or more to Approve
Cards with Side A + Side B (ex: Transform cards) will be graded as one card, but count as two cards towards your 7.Though flavor text factors into the overall design, the presence of flavor text vs no flavor text should be the main tiebreaker if judges split decision or give same grade for two cards.
We're willing to provide a trial run this season to see if it's worth the time for the following:
Yes - that's how we judge them. The majority voted to keep it that way.
@Robo_Kitty
Love it!
@kaoz42
Your most recent 7
Finally!
One thing tho... avoid blank creatures... you know?
Also, if you could put custom mechanics in the comments if it's not in the card
*Enters 3 blank 2/2 creatures into the tournament*
I'm so gonna win.
Thanks! I really honestly hate to give you more work... i don't want to... maybe we can figure something else out... like you can send me a message with your mechanic (as if it were on MTGFandom) that way we have it...
I just remember seeing plenty of cards with mechanics out of the blue, and until we memorize them... haha ... we forget what we're reading
Season 8: July-September
Once a year, we'd like to have a little fun and drop everyone's hat into the same bag.Week 1 Schedule (Starts this week)