MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Thoughts for Thursdays
Judging Practice
What do we got now, jpastor???
- Each week, I'm going to post cards certain participants in this thread have created.
- All you have to do to participate in this discussion is view the cards posted for the week, then private message me your vote for which one you think is the best card.
- In your private message to me, you will also include one card of your choice that you've created...
- At the end of the week, I'll announce the winning cards, based on the votes submitted to me throughout the week.
- Then, everyone who voted for the winning card will have the card they turned in to me added to the list to be judged in the next week's group of cards.
- Also, prize(s) for the creator of the winning card each week
As for the Judging Leaderboard
- Every 3 entries you judge = +1 Score
- Every 2 correct judgements = +1 Score
- Every 4 votes you receive on your cards = +1 Score
- Every 5 points = +1 Score
- 1st Place = +5 Points
- 2nd Place = +3 Points
- 3rd Place = +1 Point
This discussion has been closed.
Comments
Week 1 - Limelight Quintuplets
To get things going, I just picked the most recently created card by each of my top five mystery boxers of all time. Again, all you have to do to participate is private message me your vote for the best card in this bunch, as well as a link to one of your own cards.In no particular order:
Fortuna, Goddess of Luck by @JoeMoose
Dragonform Dance by @bnew07
Theina, Foxy Musician by @sorinjace
Vritri the Fickle by @TenebrisNemo
Fiend-Blood Ritual by @Ranshi
I sent you a PM.
Keep em coming! Have a good rest of your weekend everyone.
New cards posted tomorrow
Week 1 Results
Winning Card: Fiend-Blood Ritual by @Ranshi
Breakdown of votes:- Fiend-Blood Ritual (6)
- Vritiri the Fickle (3)
- Theina, Foxy Musician (2)
Ranshi's prize for first place = You may have jpastor donate 2 favorites to the cardsmith of your choice + you get 1 favorite of jpastor's choice.Judging Leaderboard
Week 2 - The Prepossessing Six
Some cardsmiths are sharing quite lengthy reviews of each of the week's cards when they post their vote, and I don't want that to go to waste.
I'm happy for you to share anything from me, and for anyone to ask me to clarify anything that might be shared of my feedback. I think we're all working to create better card designs with the feedback we are provided, but I think providing constructive feedback ourselves can be equally challenging, and sharing our judging process with each other could be helpful.
Need 5 more voted to exceed last week's count!
Hi everyone, last day for voting for Week 2's cards: "The Prepossessing Six"
To clarify,
You do NOT need to provide justification for your vote.. you can simply say "I vote for [blank], and here's my card."
Week 2 Results
Winning card: Blessing of Roots by @Tomigon
Breakdown of votes:- Blessing of Roots (5)
- Rakdos Chainwalker (2)
- Takeshi (1)
Tomigon's prize for first place = Five favorites of your choice - choose one card from each of your following pages for me to favorite:Judging Leaderboard
Week 3 - The Preposterous Five