MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
5-Color EDH!
Hey everyone! My contests don't usually get member, so I hope this gets more than usual! For this I want you to make A 5-color commander that you would be interested to play with in real life! Like this-
Any questions, call in close! This will be closed for judging at March 03, and the results will probably come out at march 05! Two honorable mentions and the top three! Prizes are-
NO old cards allowed, feedback on the card above greatly appreciated. Max of 4 entries, and have a nice day!
Any questions, call in close! This will be closed for judging at March 03, and the results will probably come out at march 05! Two honorable mentions and the top three! Prizes are-
- 1st place-A follow and nine like of your choice. (+ a place in the hall of fame and a trophy)
- 2nd place-Eight likes of your choice. (+ a place in the hall of fame and a trophy)
- 3rd place-Five likes of your choice. (+ a place in the hall of fame and a trophy)
- Honorable mentions-Faves on all your entries and an additional fave of your choice!
NO old cards allowed, feedback on the card above greatly appreciated. Max of 4 entries, and have a nice day!
Comments
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/ganford-the-wanderer
The rank up mechanic allows him to branch out into many different options to build a deck. Do you want a non-creature based deck? He can do that. Aggro? Yup. Eldrazi? Of course!
I may have made some wording mistakes, so the rulings may be off, but the idea is that if you target him with a red and blue spell, you can rank him up into a creature that is either red or blue (or both).
Here are the ranked up forms so far (I may make more):
(Note: In order to rank up into the colorless form, you must target him with a colorless spell.)
I didn't know how else to make a creature rank up, other than exile (I thought about mutate, but that just allows the creature to rank up again, which I didn't want), so in order to make this not busted, Ganford, the Wanderer can only be put into the command zone from exile once its ranked up form leaves the battlefield.
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/macie-glum-painter?list=set&set=57095
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/ayquiren-alliance
Here's an old card. An actual old card, not like these new "old" cards. Pfft.
An old card of mine
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/spark-of-dominaria
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/red-mirrored
Here's two old ones from my set. Reckoning plays better with multicolor five-color (think Niv-Mizzet Reborn), and Hetzica acts as a commander lord for the creature classes that are a focus for the set
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/mystra-soul-of-the-weave
If you want to see all the cards I've made to go along with him, here's the link: https://mtgcardsmith.com/account/sets/43694
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/chromina-dominarch
New prizes and rules-
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/elthorin-the-instructor
3rd place- Hivit, the Living Avatar by @RohanDragoon.
I really like the hexproof on this. Very creative and unique!
2nd place- Macie, Glum Painter by @Usaername
I like the way this is mono-colored with a trigger fir multi-colors. My only gripe here is that this isn't really a black ability?
And the winner....
Drumroll please....
Ay'Quiren Alliance by @Suicidal_Deity!!!!A very old card from 2016, but this one is a corker! Very unique creativity, with an enchantment that can be your commander, flavour and balance! You have definitely inspired me!!!
I decided not to do HPs because I didn't get enough entries. Well done everyone else!
Now it's time for the prizes...
@Suicidal_Deity...
A follow and nine like of your choice. (+ a place in the hall of fame and a trophy)
@Usaername....
Eight likes of your choice. (+ a place in the hall of fame and a trophy)
And @RohanDragoon....
Five likes of your choice. (+ a place in the hall of fame and a trophy)
Here are the trophies...
Alright, now prizes. @Suicidal_Deity I followed you, and for the rest I need your favourite requests!
And as for me, I don't want any favourites, but appreciate both the contest and the recognition. If you'd like to, I would request to favourite one card from nine other smiths. Your discretion. If you find no free time, no worries. Just a way to see the favourites not go to waste.
Cheers. And again, thank you.
@Usaername Alright, this was hard, as you have a lot of awesome designs, but these eight really appealed to me!
Disoccupy This card felt like really nice new design space to me, and the art selection is very creative.
Derationalize This also cool design space, with switching color identities around. This might be underpowered, I don't know, but that's my stupid opinion.
Deconstituent The flavour on this seems very cool, akthough for me it seems to "Big-fat-creature with no intellect whatsoever" type of thing. Very cool though.
Quickdraw Outlaw I mainly like this for the rhyming name, but I like the mechanic and flavour too!
Sword of Ego and Id An Old card of your's, but an amazing one! Great drawing and abiliities, just lost for words!
Last Line
Leo, Mystic Peacekeeper