Mystery Box Challenges

1…326327329331332…342

Comments

  • jpastorjpastor
    @TheDarkKnight1234567

    Avast, ye scallywag! I'll be divin' into these cards and sharin' me thoughts with a fair rating and a splash of wisdom. 

    1. **Temporal Ruination**
    Design Rating: 85/100
    Notes: Temporal Ruination be a storm of confusion and twistin' timelines, sweepin' away spells and abilities from the stack and leavin' naught but confusion in its wake. But, aye, this spell be a bit tricky to navigate, leadin' to murky waters and long-winded explanations for the crew.

    2. **Relentless Fury**
    Design Rating: 92/100
    Notes: Relentless Fury be a rousin' battle cry for barbarians, lettin' them charge into the fray without fear of harm. The trample, first strike, and battle cry powers be a crescendo of power. Yet, the card might be treadin' close to overpowerin' waters, creatin' a horde of near-invincible warriors.

    3. **Empress Marchesa d'Amati**
    Design Rating: 90/100
    Notes: Empress Marchesa be a masterful assassin, flashin' onto the scene with deathtouch like a shadow in the night. Her rule over excess life and game victories be a devious twist, but it could lead to a bit of confusion when calculatin' the spoils of her conquests.

    4. **Primal Hymn**
    Design Rating: 88/100
    Notes: Primal Hymn be a verdant maneuver, summonin' a glimpse of nature's bounty to the field or offerin' a touch of healin'. Yet, the mechanics of revealin' cards and puttin' permanents into play might be a tad convoluted, like a forest path covered in brambles.

    5. **Moon's Revelation**
    Design Rating: 87/100
    Notes: Moon's Revelation be a mystical spectacle, flippin' the world of permanents upside down in a mesmerizin' dance. Yet, the abrupt transformation might be a bit jarring for players, like bein' caught in a sudden squall at sea.

    There ye have it, me matey! Each card be a treasure with its own unique charm, but a bit more polish could set 'em sailin' on smoother seas. Keep honin' yer craft, and ye might just find yerself chartin' a course to the treasure trove of a perfect card design. ?‍☠️⚓?
  • bloodtooth101bloodtooth101
    took 2 edits but i think i posted this right lol
  • bloodtooth101bloodtooth101
    • A Mystery Challenge: Create a card that puts specific card(s) from your library into your graveyard.
    • Extra Challenge: Create a creature card with prowess and another triggered ability.
  • bloodtooth101bloodtooth101
    i posted this on the previous page by accident because im a goof
  • TheDarkKnight1234567TheDarkKnight1234567
    edited August 2023
    Mystery Challenge: Create a permanent card that has a downside when it enters and when it dies.



    https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/twilight-sphinx-1

    Do I have to complete my Slyph Key challenge before requesting another box?

    PS: @ManInMaroon_948 sorry to keep you waiting.
  • jpastorjpastor
    @kaoz42
    Prize 34 - Chest o' Precious Brews ? Two Prize Choices in your next box! The choicest treasures of the sea await!

    @12SidedGuy
    That box o' yers be missin' a prize. I award ye a     Captured Siren ?‍♀️ You get an additional box with your next one. Your Victories Bestow Us Riches.
    Yer box also be missin' Milestone 10 - A Gem ? 5 favorites or feedback on any cards you choose

    @Robo_Kitty

    Arr, me matey! Ye be wantin' an honest reckonin', and an honest reckonin' ye shall have. Let's set sail and rate these cards, no holdin' back the blunderous thoughts:

    1. **Steampunk Innovator**
    Design Rating: 75/100
    Notes: Steampunk Innovator be a creative spark, a human artificer conjurin' a monstrous construct to the scene. The creation of a 6/6 trample machine be a sight to behold. Yet, the mechanics of drawin' a card when token artifacts pass to Davy Jones' locker might be a tad complex for the crew to grasp swiftly.

    2. **Time-Honored Prince**
    Design Rating: 85/100
    Notes: Time-Honored Prince be a noble soul with a trick up his sleeve, whiskin' creatures away to return 'em stronger and with a touch of lifelink. The weave of exile and +1/+1 counters be a deft touch, but the mechanics might lead to some eyebrow-raising on the ship's deck.

    3. **Enrage**
    Design Rating: 82/100
    Notes: Enrage be a fiery instant, coaxin' a foe's creature to join the fray with a snarl. And the stormin' overload be like a thunderclap, forcin' a whole crew to charge in. But the duality of rage be a bit puzzlin', like tryin' to steer a ship with two helms.

    Aye, there ye have it, me hearty! These cards be treasures in their own right, but a touch more polish on the mechanics might be the compass that points 'em true to the highest seas of card design. Keep fine-tunin' yer craft, and who knows, ye might just find yerself discoverin' the hidden isle of a perfect card creation. ?‍☠️⚓?

    @smax765
    Prize 8 - Pirate's Treasure ? A gem of discovery, me heartie!
  • jpastorjpastor
    PREVIOUS DEADLINE WINNERS




    @TheDarkKnight1234567 ;Milestone 25 - ❓ 2 Prizes at Random or 1 of choice
    @kaoz42 ;Milestone 10 - ?
  • TheDarkKnight1234567TheDarkKnight1234567
    edited August 2023
    Congrats guys!

    @jpastor

    I'm curious to see the bracket, any chance you could post a picture? Also, dumb question- for the milestone 25 prize (chance roll), it's referring to regular prize list, not the milestone prize list, right?

    EDIT: Thanks for the card reviews!
  • jpastorjpastor
    Yes
  • Robo_KittyRobo_Kitty
    • Mystery Challenge: Create a card that uses javelin counters.

    • Extra Challenge: Create a card that adds mana when you attack, but does not allow you to keep that mana for future steps and phases.

    Hit me with another box please!
  • TheKeefManTheKeefMan
    Oh btw forgot to ask, could I get another box please?
  • jpastorjpastor

  • jpastorjpastor
    @Robo_Kitty your mystery box contains:
    • A Mystery Challenge: Create an uncommon Construct creature that's a 1-drop or can be with cost reduction.
    @TheKeefMan your mystery box contains:
    • A Mystery Challenge: Create a mono-green Aura Curse.
  • TheKeefManTheKeefMan
    Mystery Challenge: Create a mono-green Aura Curse.



    Another box please!
  • kaoz42kaoz42
    Prompt: Create a card that cares about being equipped and has the name of an existing equipment card in its name.

    https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/zeeth-of-blackblade-reforged
    The existing artifact that is in its name is Blackblade Reforged

    @jpastor
    Another box please. For my Chest o' Precious Brews prizes, I choose the Ghostly Sphere (Steal 3), and the Captured Siren (An extra box along with the next box).
  • smax765smax765
    edited August 2023
    challenge: create a card that buffs opponent creatures.


    EDIT: Another box, please!
  • ManInMaroon_948ManInMaroon_948
    Hey @jpastor, I just noticed that you've unfavorited a lot of my cards recently, including cards I specified to gets favs like Cry for Saviors. I'm not rlly sure why this happened, and I feel a little hurt because of it.
  • Robo_KittyRobo_Kitty
    • Challenge: Create an uncommon Construct creature that's a 1-drop or can be with cost reduction.

    I’ll take another box please!
  • ManInMaroon_948ManInMaroon_948
    edited August 2023
    (Deleted)
  • 12SidedGuy12SidedGuy
    You too @ManInMaroon_948! I Hope to see you here again, your designs have been great!
  • ManInMaroon_948ManInMaroon_948
    edited August 2023
    Oops: Wrong channel. Lmao. Sorry guys.
    Thanks @12SidedGuy for the praise lmao, I appreciate it. But I ain’t done yet with my designs!
  • bloodtooth101bloodtooth101
    can i get a box plz
  • jpastorjpastor
    @ManInMaroon_948
    I'll be reapplying favorites shortly.
  • ManInMaroon_948ManInMaroon_948
    Okay, sorry I mentioned that. I was just confused...
  • jpastorjpastor
    @bloodtooth101 your mystery box contains:
    • A Mystery Challenge: Create a creature that's a jötunn.
    @Robo_Kitty your mystery box contains:
    • Pirate's Treasure ? A Gem
    • A Mystery Challenge: Create a creature with more than one way to gain {e} and spend it.
    @smax765 your mystery box contains:
    • Phantom Orb ☠️ Loot 1 entry. (It becomes yours.)
    • A Mystery Challenge: Create a white Enchantment that showcases authority.
    @kaoz42 ha - that would be an op prize.. no you get a choice between two random prizes in this box. Your mystery box contains:
    • Anchor's Weight ? Target pirate can't use their prizes until ye submit your next box.
      Cask Crasher ? Your entries can't be targeted this deadline.
    • A Mystery Challenge: Create a Sorcery with a subtype.
    @TheKeefMan your mystery box contains:
    • A Mystery Challenge: Create a common creature with a quote in the flavor text and the Journey to Nyx set symbol.
  • jpastorjpastor

    Prize List

    1Scallywag Banner ?‍☠️A Flag
    2Ghostly Sphere ☠️Loot 3 entries.
    3Cap'n's Chronicle ?Box Draft
    4Grog Gobbler ?Target pirate's targets are random this deadline and their mystery challenges become stranger.
    5Poisoned Sphere ??
    6Buccaneer's Gem ?1 Fave or Feedback on any card/cardsmith of your choice
    7Crown of Pirate Wit ?Unlimited reshuffles on all mystery challenges you get this deadline.
    8Pirate's Treasure ?5 favorites/feedback in any combination, distributed as you choose among any cards/smiths
    9Skeletal Edicts ?You get an extra challenge. Complete both for next box.
    10??
    11Riggin' Cord ?Build-a-box Draft
    12Chain Cannonball ?Blunder 2 entries.
    13Inferno Vessel ?Blunder 3 entries.
    14Crate o' Fiery Flavours ?️Two Challenge Options
    15Radiant Light ?Doubles the prize in your next box if you have a prize.
    16Fatigue Spheroid ?Target pirate in this post can't submit their entry until ye get your next box.
    17Captured Siren ?‍♀️You get an additional box with your next one.
    18Blunder Barrage ?Blunder cards with unnamed artists or ai art.
    19Hourglass of Time ⏱️Set the deadline's end for 1-5 days from now
    20??
    21Jig Juggler ?
    22Elder Scope ?Old card or an extra new card
    23??
    24Contraband Cargo ?You may submit an additional card you made for another discussion with your card for this box.
    25Swashbuckler Steins ?Gift a box!
    26??
    27Ornate Skeleton Key ⚙️You get an undiscovered prize in your next box. 
    28??
    29Pirate's Brew ?x2 options for all the remainder of the deadline
    30Luxurious Baubles ?You and another cardsmith of choice are guaranteed a prize in your next box.
    31??
    32Spectral Sphere ☠️Loot 2 entries.
    33Navigator's Needle ?Reshuffle this box's challenge any number of times.
    34Chest o' Precious Brews ?Two Prize Choices in your next box!
    35Anchor's Weight ?Target pirate can't use their prizes until ye submit your next box.
    36Hexed Skeletal Remains ?Skeleton Draft -or- Your Mystery Challenge
    37??
    38??
    39Cap'n Jadefire's Macaque ?You get 2-5 prizes from this page, selected at random.
    40Enigma Chart ?Complete 1-5 Challenges to earn 1-5 prizes
    41Miniature Marauders ?CS Masters Draft -or- do your mystery challenge
    42Mast Swinger ?Pirates with more entries than you can't target you or your entries this deadline.
    43Drowsy Sphere ?Use this to counter a target.
    44??
    45Matey Macaw ?The parrot be your comrade till the very end, steering ye toward the challenge of your choice from the riddles found in the same message as your enigmatic chest.
    46Cap'n Cadstar's Clue Holder ?️2-5 keys used to open your boxes this deadline, each generates something specific (create them on the spot)
    47Pirate's Plunder ?4 favorites/feedback in any combination, distributed as you choose among any cards/smiths
    48??
    49??
    50Rewards of the Reaper ?Last entry rated 1-5 = # of favorites
  • kaoz42kaoz42
    Prompt: Create a Sorcery with a subtype.

    https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/o-kagachis-vengeance
    @jpastor
    Another box please. I'm still waiting for an oppurtunity to use the anchor's weight.

  • cadstar369cadstar369
    @kaoz42 remember one's prizes held become forfeit whenever they receive their next mystery box. (Holding on to them is part of a prestige perk.)
  • jpastorjpastor
    Pirate's Mystery Challenge

    Ahoy there, ye scallywags!

    Yer mystery box be holdin' a grand challenge for ye, @kaoz42! Set yer sights on this:

    A Mystery Challenge: Create a card that transforms into a Legendary Land and create that Legendary Land.

    Arrr, a challenge worthy of a true swashbucklin' decksmith! Let yer creativity run wild, and may ye conjure up a tale that unfolds like the secrets of the open sea.

  • kaoz42kaoz42

    A Mystery Challenge: Create a card that transforms into a Legendary Land and create that Legendary Land.


    https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/seeker-of-aurilanth?list=user
    Tranformation:

    https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/aurilanth-city-of-dragons?list=user

    @jpastor
    Another box please.

This discussion has been closed.