Should anyone need any explanations, feel free to seek out the characters in the cantina of Mystery Box World to examine the criterion in further detail or receive feedback.
@jaceberlin you around these days? we have a few peeps who are less active than you've been the past few months and you're more than welcome to return if you wish!
I have to say, I don't know how I'm doing so well. Me being where I was before week 5 was surprising in and of itself but I was like 95% sure @Ranshi was going to win against me.
@Daedalus_The_All_Father I did start you in the top division for a reason. Seems like you're making me not regret that. Also Ranshi is not good at cardsmithing.
@Ranshi Maybe both? I do like a lot of your cards though.
@jpastor Well I aim to please, or purposefully irritate but I typically try to save that for people I know in real life cause it gets them all flustered and it's fun to watch.
@TheKeefMan Fancy to meet ya there. I wanted to know whenever you would like to drop out, redraw, or submit your card for the Battle Mystery Card, we missed ya.
MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Comments
This week was none other than the scallywag pirate, Malakai.
Week 1 - Judging Criteria: Concept & Novelty
Week 2 - Judging Criteria: Balance & Fairness
Week 3 - Judging Criteria: Mana Cost, P/T (creatures only), & Rarity
Week 4 - Judging Criteria: Versatility & Cost-Effectiveness
Week 5 - Judging Criteria -?
Week 6 - Judging Criteria -?
Week 7 - Judging Criteria -?
Week 8 - Judging Criteria -?
Should anyone need any explanations, feel free to seek out the characters in the cantina of Mystery Box World to examine the criterion in further detail or receive feedback.
Thanks
Question - are the 7 rankings (per round) on Challonge from your oldest card to your newest card, or from your newest card to your oldest card?
jpastor | MTG Cardsmith
you around these days? we have a few peeps who are less active than you've been the past few months and you're more than welcome to return if you wish!
Last week was Versatility & Cost-Effectiveness
Week 1 - Judging Criteria: Concept & Novelty
Week 2 - Judging Criteria: Balance & Fairness
Week 3 - Judging Criteria: Mana Cost, P/T (creatures only), & Rarity
Week 4 - Judging Criteria: Versatility & Cost-Effectiveness
Week 5 - Judging Criteria: Flavor Text & Storytelling
Week 6 - Judging Criteria -?
Week 7 - Judging Criteria -?
Week 8 - Judging Criteria -?
I did start you in the top division for a reason. Seems like you're making me not regret that. Also Ranshi is not good at cardsmithing.
@jpastor Well I aim to please, or purposefully irritate but I typically try to save that for people I know in real life cause it gets them all flustered and it's fun to watch.
Week 2 - Judging Criteria: Balance & Fairness
Week 3 - Judging Criteria: Mana Cost, P/T (creatures only), & Rarity
Week 4 - Judging Criteria: Versatility & Cost-Effectiveness
Week 5 - Judging Criteria: Flavor Text & Storytelling
Week 6 - Judging Criteria: Abilities & Balance Across Formats
Week 7 - Judging Criteria -?
Week 8 - Judging Criteria -?
@12SidedGuy - 6 cards
@Elyas_Sterling - 5 cards
@exaltedmarauder - 7 cards
@Globert-the-Martian - 7 cards
@Hinges - 2 cards
@Laharl897 - 7 cards
@kaoz42 - 1 card
@KorandAngels - 5 cards
@Korora12 - 7 cards
@ManInMaroon_948 - 2 cards
@Ranshi - 5 cards
@SlammySam - 7 cards
@SpellPiper2213 - 5 cards
@spookoops - 6 cards
@Suicidal_Deity - 7 cards
@TheDarkKnight1234567 - 1 card
I made a card last night (acolyte of the abyss), so do I still need to made another?
Fancy to meet ya there. I wanted to know whenever you would like to drop out, redraw, or submit your card for the Battle Mystery Card, we missed ya.
Week 2 - Judging Criteria: Balance & Fairness
Week 3 - Judging Criteria: Mana Cost, P/T (creatures only), & Rarity
Week 4 - Judging Criteria: Versatility & Cost-Effectiveness
Week 5 - Judging Criteria: Flavor Text & Storytelling
Week 6 - Judging Criteria: Abilities & Balance Across Formats
Week 7 - Judging Criteria: Card Text Clarity & Elegance
Week 8 - Judging Criteria: Longevity
Cardsmith League - Season 9 - Challonge
Top 3 get 10〽️ each/win.
Cardsmith League - Playoffs - Season 9 - Challonge
Do the deferent divisions - A, B, and C correspond to deferent "skill levels" or are they just to break everyone into groups?