MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Post your cards here, see what others think
This discussion has been closed.
Howdy, Stranger!
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
Comments
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/timinara-first-to-discover?list=user
Tragic Arrogance sacrifices the same amount. Also 55 is how many years Stephen Hawking lived since he was diagnosed with 2 years to live.
Cards like Tragic Arrogance, Cataclysm, Balance make all players sacrifice permanents. I think they are different. But white does have cards that sacrifice permanents to gain life, such as Renounce. However it's very old card.
Yeah I knew the reference. It's a cool idea:)
Thinking I need to add (This effect lasts indefinitely.) at the end.
@TenebrisNemo
You can't add card you don't own to your hand. If that card is shuffled into your library, you might forget giving it back to its owner after the game.
You can use exile for that card instead.
-----------
When Perfect Thieving is countered, an opponent creates a 3/3 Human creature token.
Look at the top two cards of an opponent's library and exile one to them. For the rest of the game, you may play that card. You may spend mana as though it were mana of any type to cast it.
-----------
*Personally, if the name is "Perfect", I think it can have split second instead of "When Perfect Thieving is countered, .." part.
*Thieving theme cards are basically blue.
A place that's just a lush land at first. Then a massive gravitational shift occurred when the Eldrazi arrived, causing giant waves to breach and flood the Colispire's shorelines regularly. When the waters recede, workers of the Colispire factory find stranded sea creatures, struggling to survive. So they get creative and cosmetically enhance them in their factory, using them as a form of defense against the enemy Eldrazi.
@jpastor, please remember to credit your artists. I really like the flavor of Massive Crushing (methinks a better name perhaps?), but find it jarring that footprints can produce mana. Sure, there's enough black and green mana ready to be tapped in my feet right now, but it just seems curious. Colispire may be better as {3} instead of risking another powerful Storm card.
@TheCenterOfTheUniverse, this actually looks like a fair use of Annihilator! Nice starting creature that also works late game. Excellent design.
@Tomigon, Bullfighter seems really cool and balanced. Instead of having the bull run around and kill stuff, you could zone back the power and toughness of the bullfighter and have something like "Whenever an Ox an opponent controls dies, return it to the battlefield under your control." Just a cool idea.
@Faiths_Guide, is there any reason to play Forethought Automaton over a Memnite? Maybe it could be a 1/0 instead.
Thoughts?
Thanks for the feedback! You suggested "Whenever an Ox an opponent controls dies, return it to the battlefield under your control.", but Ox is a token.. it disappears when it dies.
Stalwart Shinobi is a neat common, but it seems a bit difficult to survive the first combat. Also I think it can say "this creature" in the reminder instead of the card's name.
And "Shinobi" meas "Ninja" in Japanese. Ninjas are stealth master backstabber with many nasty tricks and weapons.. Very opposite to Samurais who fight face to face. Samurais are also called "Bushi", "Musha", "Ashigaru(Foot-soldier)", "Mononofu" fyi.
Feedback:
1) + abilities are always above - abilities.
2) The card could use some additional punctuation. (Minor.)
3) The card feels incredibly slow for the casting cost.
It is an interesting design though.
I've finally created the final version of my champion! What do your think?
Maybe Forethought could be an 0/1? I dunno. Thanks for the input!
Your Shinobi is cool for sure!
Created for the "Alien" contest.
Posted some feedback on your card.
Thoughts?
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/mind-snag-nephilim
What do you think about this?
I'm trying to come up with an ability for a b/w/g set I'm making any thoughts on it?