MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Cardsmith Compliation Competition - (You may sign up for round 4.)
This discussion has been closed.
Howdy, Stranger!
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
Comments
Whose Participating?
I feel this question is already answered...
Shall we have self decided teams after all people have signed up?
When teams are self decided people tend to stick with people they already know...
Shall we have teams be chosen by team captain?
Same problem as above, however it's less extreme.
Shall we have multiple rounds?
If you want, I don't feel it's necessary
After each round, should teams be chosen again and switched with different number of team members?
If we're doing multiple rounds, yes.
How many people should be in each team?
Three of Four?
Since I'm not a loner and I want to join to, can I join and have the winner be voted (because entries will be few)?
Sure!
Should I have all cards made in 1 set?
That would be a little confusing, unless all teams had a separate guild/shard/wedge.
Should all the cards just be posted separately (I wouldn't suggest that)?
Probably not
Should we have a premium member in each team so all cards they decide on will be put in that set (They could be team captains, but I don't think there are enough premium members)?
Sounds good
Should I get a good hearted person like @Corwinnn to make a set for each team?
Also sounds good.
Can the winner be chosen by popular vote?
I like this idea!
Should we name our teams?
Of course!
Most importantly, what should the contest exactly be on? Note that each one will be different.
Creativity? Balance/Power? Innovation?
Me, of course.
Shall we have self decided teams after all people have signed up?
I prefer things to be random
Shall we have teams be chosen by team captain?
Sure!
Shall we have multiple rounds?
Why not?
After each round, should teams be chosen again and switched with different number of team members?
No. That would be rather time consuming and pointless.
How many people should be in each team?
Five.
Since I'm not a loner and I want to join to, can I join and have the winner be voted (because entries will be few)?
Sure?
Should I have all cards made in 1 set?
Yes.
Should all the cards just be posted separately (I wouldn't suggest that)?
No.
Should we have a premium member in each team so all cards they decide on will be put in that set (They could be team captains, but I don't think there are enough premium members)?
No. That would be rather dumb.
Should I get a good hearted person like @Corwinnn to make a set for each team?
Yes.
Can the winner be chosen by popular vote?
Yes.
Should we name our teams?
Is this even a question. It answers itself.
Most importantly, what should the contest exactly be on? Note that each one will be different.
It should be on Unique Mechanics that we have to build around.
@Latinas
@TrippleBoggey3
@Ningyounk
@Littledemon
@Lujikul
@TheEverspikesWarlord
@DingusXeon
@OneBigBlueSky
@Monty
@TurkeyAsylum
@KrampisZman
@Yururu
@Feyamius
@KrazyKobolbs98
@DashDo101
@Mila
@Flatfish
@DankSoulsRager
@JAM
@Beeswax
@UndeadZombie
@Faiths_Guide
@Mordecai
@BobSmob
All of you are members for round 2, so I want the topic of contest 2 to be decided by you guys:
What do you want round 2's contest to be on?
A: A normal set, but without restrictions.
B: A full professional deck
C: A set based on something specific, like certain mechanics, a certain species (@Monty would be doing Womps), stuff like that.
E: Dual Decks
F: A story, and cards made for the story.
G: From the Vault
H: Premium Deck
I: Event Deck
J: Other (Specify Below)
I am a premium member for the next 3 months, so I can now serve as a team captain