MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Post your cards here, see what others think
This discussion has been closed.
Howdy, Stranger!
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
Comments
My wording suggestion is
--------
Defender
Boneyard -- Whenever one or more creatures attacks you, if Guardians of the Valley is in your graveyard, you may pay {2}{g}{g}. If you do, create a token that's a copy of Guardians of the Valley for each attacking creature. Exile the tokens at end of combat.
--------
The card seems op.. I think this should exile it from your graveyard when you use Boneyard ability so that it can't be repeatable.
Sorry, I didn't read it carefully! If you exile the card, I think the card power is ok.
Opinions
So I challenged myself to create one of my own. Thoughts please!
Thoughts @Faiths_Guide?
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/hunted-hellkite
For reasons unknown, Disqus sign in is down (or at least experiencing errors). What I would've commented there is this:
Interestingly, I was just working out a card which had to do with creatures under no players control. I think, perhaps, that the hellkite should be declared as attacking a non-active player each combat (it would be weird if the "attacking player" were being attacked simultaneously). Since he's designed for Commander, it seems reasonable just to make that addition to the rules text - "...attacks a non-active player chosen at random each combat..." As this card is so unique, and difficult to imagine in action, I'm unsure if this helps/hurts balance or function, but I think, at least, it helps to simplify its action. I don't think I have any good suggestion for truncation, but I applaud your "outside-the-box" tact and current resolution.
*ThumbsUp*
P.S. I think your Nephilim might need some wording revision; perhaps even a bit of redesign.
1) Spells cast on the stack of this spell don't gain priority and do not resolve until this spell resolves.
2) Abilities that are activated or triggered on the stack don't resolve until this spell resolves.
I'm trying to take it a step further than a simple "When you cast this spell" ability that many Eldrazi have, and I'm also looking to make it different from Split Second. In other words, you can still activate abilities and cast spells in response, unlike Split Second, but none of them take place until this spell resolves.
Essentially emerge but naming the only valid sacs. Also pays for colored mana for now, that could change, though I doubt it. I'm sure the mono color commanders need more work than anything else and it's hard to find 15 sets of 2 pieces of art for this sort of thing, so I used Fire Emblem Cipher cards' art, please don't take these cards any less seriously because of that. The only effect that had was making most everything a human instead of throwing in a different creature type on a couple of them.
https://mtgcardsmith.com/user/LeBateauIvre/sets/28478
https://mtgcardsmith.com/user/LeBateauIvre/sets/28541
Also since it is may remove counters from quati he is able to distribute more effectively
Reclaim (You may have a standard size sideboard, including this card. You may look at your sideboard and you may play this card from your sideboard by exiling a card from your hand in addition to any other costs.)
Reclaim 2 (You may have a standard size sideboard, including this card. You may look at your sideboard and you may play this card from your sideboard by exiling two cards from your hand in addition to any other costs.)
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/fall-from-grace-5
@Degen