MTG Custom Card Reviews

jpastor · October 22

Drop cards you want reviewed in a short video on social media platforms.

MTG Custom Card Reviews - YouTube
MTG Custom Card Reviews (@mtgccr) / X
MTG Custom Card Reviews (@custommtgcreations) | TikTok
Instagram

LvB · October 23

Since many people liked it, review this

jpastor · October 24

@LvB -
---Scheduled for 8:30PM CT---
https://youtube.com/shorts/bcc5lR8tHcM/
MTG Custom Card Reviews (@mtgccr) / X
a dedicated review of The Quacken MTG custom card or a series of fan-m... | TikTok

---Already live on---
Instagram

LvB · October 25

Uh, the AI Voice in the review is weird xD

Better use your own voice, maybe with some effects on it, but AI voice really aint good with its false pronounciations and strange stops in the middle of the sentence and such.

And beside that, everyone here is really excited to hear the real jpastor ^^

jpastor · October 25

okay - here's the new one - scheduled for 8:30 pm CT
https://youtube.com/shorts/7cifch2pwYw
https://www.tiktok.com/@custommtgcreations/video/7565294105828379935?
MTG Custom Card Reviews (@mtgccr) / X

https://www.instagram.com/reel/DQP92n4D6oJ/

jpastor · October 26

i'm quitting magic - every mtg player hates ai - and my phone is ai - so every time i look at it - I feel like a villain to mtg

LvB · October 26

Personally, i dont hate ai, but that ai voice in the review just wasnt good and it sounds weird. Maybe theres better ai voices out there, i dont know. But a real voice is way better.

StuffnSuch · November 6

@jpastor I don't hate AI! I believe it to be a useful and powerful tool for those that use it responsibly and effectively. I do believe that there's a lot of terrible garbage that AI spews out, but I also believe that humanity is discerning enough to eventually pull out of the content generating spiral we're currently in and have a new renaissance of sorts where we redefine our expectations on what qualifies as worthwhile in what we consume, leaving the senseless drivel behind and rediscovering content that is meaningful and valuable. I agree, the AI voice you're using is a little wonky, and I'd certainly hate for one of my favorite people still working these threads to be amongst the senseless drivel left behind. I support you using your natural voice, but also support you exploring AI options along the way as you see fit.

kaoz42 · November 7

@jpastor You're not a villain to mtg just because you use ai, anyway [insert meaningful words etc...]

melovecatz · November 10

are you still doing this?

jpastor · November 11

@melovecatz yes

LvB · November 11

i asked ai to make a really complicated card and well ... review this !

(and please explain what it actually does)

Image: https://forums.mtgcardsmith.com/uploads/editor/rp/jgpj64a789xq.jpg

jpastor · November 12

@LvB - Scheduled for 12:30 CST Wednesday:

LvB · November 12

Ive looked it up. The mana cost of token copies is the same converted mana cost as the permanent it has copied. If you have a token copy of a serra Angel, the converted mana cost of the token is five. So the repeat thing works!

And tokens that are not copies like food tokens or treasure tokens have a CMC of zero. So it would work with permanents that cost 0 mana, like moxes for example.

And is i understood it, EVERYTHING on this card is an ETB ability. The "AND" in the middle, in my opinion means, if the first ETB trigger is activated, then look if other conditions are met, and if they are another ETB ability triggers that is able to repeat itself.

It works like this i think?!?

Image: https://forums.mtgcardsmith.com/uploads/editor/gk/54gzbx651680.jpg

And YES, this card is completely unplayable xD

Might be fun though to play it on an official tournament, then call a judge and ask him to explain what the card does

StuffnSuch · November 13

Yeah, the card is surprisingly consistent and logical, considering how convoluted it is. The single "and" being changed to "Then", and getting rid of the more tokens in your graveyard than cards clause, would make it completely functional. Oh, and you'd have to specify "permanent card type" when revealing the top seven cards, otherwise you're making non-legendary token copies of instants and sorceries on the battlefield, which, I know is addressed in the rules somewhere, but also isn't something ever intentionally built into cards. It's also really weird that it gives a bunch of combat abilities on an ETB without granting haste, but, you're in Grixis, you can haste it up if you want to take advantage of a vigilant lifelinker in colors that don't get that very often.

LvB · November 14

AI made a card that is surprisingly playable!

Image: https://forums.mtgcardsmith.com/uploads/editor/zv/22ejaaekn9ix.jpg

melovecatz · November 14

i have no idea what inspired me to make this card.

Image: https://forums.mtgcardsmith.com/uploads/editor/em/wg74wudhd765.png

LvB · November 15

Five-tastic ^^

melovecatz · November 16

@jpastor ;
i was wondering if you could maybe review this card ↑

StuffnSuch · November 17

@LvB Paradoxical Confluence would make a lot more sense if it just said "other permanents" rather than just satisfying all of it's own conditions. As it is, it'd be quite a trick to not have it just do all the things.