Mystery Challenge Quest

  1. Ask me what card you should create
  2. Create and submit the card I ask you to create, or submit a card you've already created that matches the prompt.
  3. You'll receive a grade on your card (1-5).
  4. The grade earns you that many points.
  5. Cash your points in for prizes at any point in time.
  6. Repeat steps 1-5 endlessly!
Prizes (Switch to landscape orientation if on phone.)
  • The number on the right indicates the prize's price (in points).
  • These will be posted at the top of every page for convenience.
  • Prices may change over time.
  • Prizes may be added over time.
Orb Choose the card type you'd like to make for your next mystery challenge. 1
Pearl Choose the color you'd like for your next mystery challenge. 1
Artwork Your challenge will contain a given artwork. 2
Rose Request feedback on your entry. 3
Unreal You'll receive a whacky mystery challenge. 3
Photography You will receive a mystery challenge to photograph something for your card's artwork. 4
Crackers You'll choose between two mystery challenges for your next one. 4
Mot du Jour Receive a mystery challenge to create a card using the word of the day. 4
Rosetta Stone You may submit any newly created card instead of a card specifically for your challenge. 5
Extra Entries You may submit two entries for this mystery challenge. 7
Tumult Receive a dangerously difficult mystery challenge. 7
Favorites one-five 8
Extra Credit An extra entry from another contest 8
Cardsmiths Against Humanity Receive an odd fill-in-the-blank mystery challenge 9
DJ Credentials Add one to five songs to the Spotify playlist. 10
Pic Pick Choose jpastor's next profile pic 12
Spellweb Receive your next Spellweb 13
A follow 14
Weather Change Will impact everyone's mystery challenges the remainder of the page. 14
Mystery Prize A random prize under 40 15
Bundle of Challenges two-five 15
Sculpture I'll create a card of you. 16
Briber's Purse Favorite X of jpastor's cards in exchange for you choice in prize from amongst X randomly chosen prizes under 40. 17
One month of favorites Pick a month 18
Reversal Give jpastor a challenge 18
Mini-Encounter Face a problem and submit some cards to solve it. 19
Selective Manifestation Open an Event of your choice in Legends Rising 20
One set of favorites 22
Spider Silk Receive your next Spellweb with the colors of your choice 23
Adventure Go on an adventure with some challenges. 24
Jadefire Special a bundle of two-five random prizes under 40 25
Encounter You'll face a situation with many challenges. 27
Planet Coaster Challenge jpastor to create something in particular on Planet Coaster 33
Campaign You'll go on a campaign with multiple mystery challenges. 36
MTG Cardsmith Sticker 45
Mystery Box Invitational Qualification 50
Mystery Box Avatar 55
Featured Card 65
Gifted Premium 75
Playmat 250
Blog Feature or re-feature 500
«13456

Comments

  • What card should I create?
  • @Corwinnn
    • Create a creature card with Madness Black (If you discard this card, discard it into exile. When you do, cast it for its madness cost or put it into your graveyard.)
  • What card should I create?
  • @cadstar369
    • Create a one mana creature with a majority of the card being flavor text.

  • Create a creature card with Madness Black (If you discard this card, discard it into exile. When you do, cast it for its madness cost or put it into your graveyard.)

    Dreamwrecker

    What card shall I next create?
  • @Corwinnn
    • You've earned 3 points!
    • Create a creature with power 1, toughness 2, and mana value 3.
  • I'm on it!
    • Create a creature with power 1, toughness 2, and mana value 3.

    Little Darkling

    Next I will make a card that does what?
  • @Corwinnn, I'll go with 4 points on that one because the challenge was pretty limiting! Well worked!
    • +4 points = 7 points
    • Create a creature that's a mummy with a triggered ability when it dies.

  • False Advertising Box ~ Mystery Challenge: Create a Legendary Land that creates a Legendary Creature token. (Create the token for an additional entry.)


    Quest ~ Create a one mana creature with a majority of the card being flavor text.
    The token creator is severely limited, so Kenja didn't come out properly. :disappointed:

    Eichi Temple of Wisdom Kenja Wandering Poet

    What shall I create next? :)
  • edited September 19
    @cadstar369
    • You earned 2 points for the land
    • You earned 3 points for the 1-mana creature
    • Create a card with of a new type that would be used in Commander.
  • @jpastor could you clarify what 'would' means here? Do you mean that the card I create should require commanders to be effective, or that it should be much more effective in a commander environment as opposed to other formats, or something else entirely? 
  • edited September 19
    It's a card type designed for Commander. @cadstar369

  • Quest ~ Create a card with of a new type that would be used in Commander.

    Springjack Plains

    What should I make next?
  • @cadstar369
    • You earned 4 points.
    • Create a green Sorcery that costs at least GreenGreenGreen.
  • Quest ~ Create a green Sorcery that costs at least {g}{g}{g}.
    Primal Rampage

    What should I create next? :)
    • Create a creature that's a mummy with a triggered ability when it dies.
    I nearly forgot! I'll start looking for Art when I get home from work
  • @cadstar369
    • You earned 3 points for the entry
    • Create a non-Snow card with snow in the artwork.
  • Quest ~ Create a non-Snow card with snow in the artwork.
    Follow the Aurora

    What's next on the to-create list? :)
  • What card I should create?
  • :::The air in the room suddenly went still:::

    :::Everyone collectively held their breath:::

    :::A light burst forth from above:::

    :::And then the heavens above opened up and a small sliver of paper floated down into SD's open hand:::

    Don't you judge me, I'm bored at work!
  • @cadstar369
    • You earned 2 points.

    @Suicidal_Deity
    • Create an Avatar creature with an additional subtype.
    • Create a creature that's a mummy with a triggered ability when it dies.
    Blight Mummy

    What card should I create?
  • @Corwinnn
    • Dammit Bob! Why'd you open the sarcophagus? You earned 3 points.
    • Create an Variable Colorless spell with a non-Variable Colorless kicker cost.
  • Quest ~ Create a card that mentions the Church of Dusk in its flavor text.
    Reckless Iconoclast

    Typo in the flavor text is because I made it on mobile, and my phone apparently makes the wrong apostrophe & quotation marks; don't feel like fixing it right now. :disappointed:

    What's up next? :)
  • Create an Avatar creature with an additional subtype.

    The Priest

    https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/the-priest-5

    What card should create?
  • @jpastor, what card should I create?
    • Create an Variable Colorless spell with a non-Variable Colorless kicker cost.
    Hail of Swords
  • @cadstar369
    • You earned 2 points.
    • Create a new Planeswalker for the Amonkhet plane.
  • @Suicidal_Deity
    • You earned 3 points.
    • Create a card that makes an opponent choose something.

    @Zaheer_The_Grim
    • Create a creature with power 0 and trample.

Sign In or Register to comment.