Great example, @Tomigon! You can also try a few different approaches to how Tomigon demonstrated, @EnvyReaper. The inside of the mouth could be transparent or filled in matching the border color (white/black) etc.
Ok @Tomigon I came up with a rough symbol for the bottom left symbol I don't think it is that bad but if you don't think it is good please tell me so I don't waste time on it
@EnvyReaper Nice work! But if it is compared to real set symbol, your symbol's outlines are thin. You can make it twice as thicker than that. Check this out: And the upper parts are very narrow. Can you make them wider?
@EnvyReaper Very nice! Thanks! I especially like the rare symbol. Shading is nicely done.
Sorry, few more requests.. 1) Can you make the uncommon symbol a little darker? (Also fyi, color for uncommon is slightly blueish gray. Make the contrast of dark area and bright area stronger so that it seems more metallic.) This is what I would do:
2) If I see the rare symbol, center is the brightest. But that's opposite in the mythic.. And the contrast of light and dark seems weak in mythic too.
I feel like being that you already have an accepted one, it would be kinda ridiculous to submit another, being that with the custom icon function, it becomes *sadly* less relevant.
@EnvyReaper They are better now. One little more thing is.. in uncommon symbol, the highlight part is added horizontally like I suggested. But in rare and mythic symbol, highlight part is a dot in the center.. If you see real set symbols, from uncommon to mythic, the way highlight part is added doesn't change.
@Tomigon Would you be able to take your version of the "Maw" symbol and post the 4 rarities here in two versions, one with a transparent center and one filled in (white/black)?
Ughhhhhhh @Tomigon can you provide me some hex symbols that would work for my Mythic Rare version of Fractured as I can't make it look appealing please?
MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Comments
Outlines are important. Without outlines, the symbol seem very weak on cards.
This is what you could do with @Faiths_Guide's request
Here are more challenges for you! >:D
I don't think it is that bad but if you don't think it is good please tell me so I don't waste time on it
Nice work! But if it is compared to real set symbol, your symbol's outlines are thin. You can make it twice as thicker than that.
Check this out:
And the upper parts are very narrow. Can you make them wider?
Tested on a card:
Common
Uncommon
Rare
Mythic Rare
Here is the links:
Common
Uncommon
Rare
Mythic Rare
Very nice! Thanks! I especially like the rare symbol. Shading is nicely done.
Sorry, few more requests..
1) Can you make the uncommon symbol a little darker? (Also fyi, color for uncommon is slightly blueish gray. Make the contrast of dark area and bright area stronger so that it seems more metallic.)
This is what I would do:
2) If I see the rare symbol, center is the brightest. But that's opposite in the mythic.. And the contrast of light and dark seems weak in mythic too.
Sorry for nit picking. But if those things are fixed, they are perfect. You can post them to this thread:
http://forums.mtgcardsmith.com/discussion/4147/custom-set-symbol-urls#latest
yes, also I might not submit it yet because I need the two months premium from the set icon bounty
They are better now. One little more thing is.. in uncommon symbol, the highlight part is added horizontally like I suggested. But in rare and mythic symbol, highlight part is a dot in the center.. If you see real set symbols, from uncommon to mythic, the way highlight part is added doesn't change.
Would you be able to take your version of the "Maw" symbol and post the 4 rarities here in two versions, one with a transparent center and one filled in (white/black)?
I've also refined some of the shapes:
Common
https://i.imgur.com/7e7NNw6.png
Uncommon
https://i.imgur.com/OTfufKf.png
Rare
https://i.imgur.com/Z1A247j.png
Mythic
https://i.imgur.com/8LdYv5s.png
Source: https://ya-webdesign.com/explore/werewolf-png-drawing/?utm_source=gg#1
@EnvyReaper - It seems unfinished.
Yup