@jpastor Back to normal judging for sure. Single criterion regular season rounds was an interesting experiment, but the championship should go to the best all around cardsmith.
I definitely prefer a well-rounded evaluation of a card. Most cards I make may excel in one or two categories, but have short comings in others. It wouldn't be fair if someone just happened to have a bunch of cards that are really flavorful, but otherwise garbage, that beats out someone that makes a bunch of really great cards, but they're a little more generic in their design. I don't like the mystery criteria at all, as it seems to make the design style of the person you're paired with matter more than their actual crafting ability. All around good designs should win, and we can always create a challenge elsewhere that centers on functionality or flexibility or flavor.
MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Comments
Not sure if I'm looking at the wrong account or something, but you need to have made at least 7 cards to play.
Didn't see this requirement. Thanks for this information. I will come back !
A - Middle
B - Lower
C - Upper
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/mtg-cardsmith-league
Nope. Because he is already an innkeeper ?
Do divisions still exist? I'm seeing a lot of people just type IN so I'm not too sure. If so I'd like to enter B.