MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Shelko
About
- Username
- Shelko
- Joined
- Visits
- 644
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
Thank you so much @SpellPiper2213 for hosting this nice contest and for all those very nice feedbacks! It helps me a lot to think more wisely about ways to balance those ideas for custom cards around. I really like your suggestion regarding Wul’Zekh…
-
Thanks a lot @Revan for hosting this fun contest! Also, congrats to everyone who won and participated, that was a lot of cool cards to have a look at! The same way as what has been told by the other cardsmiths out there in their previous comments, I…
-
For the mystery challenge: * Create a Squirreltopia themed Land card. I won't require another box right now, so that way it will let other cardsmith have fun creating some Squirreltopia themed cards! But once the draft is finished, I'd gladly ope…
-
For the mystery challenge box, I'd like to pick: * Create a Squirreltopia themed Land card. And for the mystery prize: * Lyric Challenge (Solo, Duel, Moshpit - Song lyrics)
-
Here's the card I've made for the following challenge: * Create a Squirreltopia themed Instant that does 2 different things. I'd gladly open another mystery box! _ _ _ Inventory(Spoiler)
-
@FireOfGolden Of course, but it works the same as Kicker/Multikicker. I'm just suggesting a wording based on those abilities that are part of the game as I think it may be a good reference point for Increase Quality. Kicker doesn't say it can only b…
-
@FireOfGolden Thank you the feedback! It indeed works against anything that would be refered as a copy, as so it would aslo affect copies of spells that are on the stack. It won't affect copies of abilities that are on the stack though, since an ab…
-
@FireOfGolden It's a really cool mechanic! As I think you could use some help with its wording, here's a little suggestion for a revised wording that works just the same: Increase Quality [cost] (You may pay an additional [cost] as you cast this sp…
-
@Corwinnn So cool! Does it work in the order you listed our usernames in your message? If it does work that way, I think I'll start this draft by picking the second mystery box's challenge available: * Create a Squirreltopia themed Instant that does…
-
@Corwinnn @jpastor Ups! I should have said it in my previous comment as I thought I'd be able to participate to the draft simply by activating the cache, but in that case I'd gladly open another mystery box please!
-
@cadstar369 Thanks a lot for your explanations and for the feedback! Now that I know more about your choices for Xerxes and K'zen, I remark that I probably was quite missing some important points on this analysis. I didn't thought about its interac…
-
(Had to cut the message in two halves as I wasn't careful enough while writing it and ended up needing to make some syntaxical edit, sorry.) All in all, I think both those cards serve a really unique archetype and they are both really nicely design…
-
@cadstar369 Xerxes, Lost Lorekeeper While I think interacting with the bottom of your library is a really neat and interesting mechanic that is yet underexploited in the game except for a few pretty ''bad'' cards (the only ones I can think about …
-
Here are my entries. First one for the commanders with ''Choose a Home'' (EDIT: it's actually a re-uploaded and corrected version from the one I've posted there earlier and from the one I've got uploaded on MTGCardsmith, since I worded it with ''Ch…
-
Gaith Fuide, Tavern Keeper Wolfish Dragon Ostentatious Sot
-
Hey! If possible, I'd like to activate this prize I got quite some time ago and didn't use yet so far: Prize 12 - Corwinnn's Cache: You can cash this prize in any time you'd like to activate a special mode that will be Squirreltopia-themed. When you…
-
Hey @Faiths_Guide ! May I request you a Food tribal artifact creature with Food subtype as a meal?
-
Here are the two Assassin cards I've created for the last mystery box challenge I got. The Assassin creature card: The Assassin non-creature card: I'd like to open another mystery box please! @jpastor @Corwinnn
-
Creatures https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/attentive-laborer https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/cautious-travellers https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/impassive-protectors-1 https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/cowardly-brute Instants and Sorceries https://mtgca…
-
For the Scarecrow challenge: And for Monster Mash challenge (it's not exactly a creature... but at the same time it's somehow still a creature): I'd like to open another mystery box, please!
-
Hey! Here are two pretty weird Vampire-themed entries. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/eldritch-legacy The second one is a double-faced card with Nightbound/Daybound from the recent Innistrad set. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/forsaken-mausole…
-
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/spooky-pumpkinsmith-2 Here's my random Scarecrow entry! EDIT: Corrected a little typo since I had written ''1'' instead of ''one.''
-
@FangQuil It's definitly a bit confusing according that they were two halves of a tournament, that were finally mixed together for the classment. I think jpastor posted an overall podium previously that stated who were the ''Grand Champion/Runner up…
-
Excuse me since I had to cut that comment in two parts since it was getting too long. - - - @Korora12 My first impressions are that it has a lovely choice of artwork. I don't know if that was intended flavorfully, but I think it's really nice tha…
-
Hey there! I'll try to give a feedback to both @cadstar369 and @Korora12 in that order. - - - Just before giving the feedbacks, I wanted to let you know that at first I was about to write a comment to say something I surely should have mentionned…
-
Thanks a lot for hosting this nice tournament and for all the judging work @jpastor! That was really fast and well organized! I wasn't expecting at all to do that well in the loser brackets, but that's a pleasant surprise! Congratularions to @TheKe…
-
@jpastor Oops, it seems that I forgot to mention you last time I wrote a message there, my bad! I'd like to open a mystery box, please!
-
Thanks a lot for your very nice feedbacks! @cadstar369 and @Tonysparks! It's a very good point that its cost can be reduced. On one side, I thiiink it may not be that bad though, since I would personally still consider it to be quite a lot of set-up…
-
Jackal next!
-
(I had to cut that comment in two parts since it was getting too long.) - - - As for myself, I'll propose a card this time! It's a ridiculous card design and it's intended to be more of a joke card than an actual serious design, but I'd like to he…